Investigating Moisture Intrusion In Roofs

Systematic, preventive roofing maintenance helps to identify and address any chinks in the building envelope armor.


https://facilityexecutive.com/2016/12/investigating-moisture-intrusion-in-roofs/
Systematic, preventive roofing maintenance helps to identify and address any chinks in the building envelope armor.
Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Investigating Moisture Intrusion In Roofs

Systematic, preventive roofing maintenance helps to identify and address any chinks in the building envelope armor.

Investigating Moisture Intrusion In Roofs

roof moisture intrusion
(Photo: The Garland Company, Inc.)

By Michael Endredi
From the November/December 2016 Issue

Moisture within a building can leave a facility manager feeling panicked, perplexed, and helpless. The myriad of moisture sources can be overwhelming; these sources can be as simple as an obvious hole in the roof or as complicated as condensation from an improperly installed vapor barrier. Unfortunately, tracking down the source of moisture intrusion within a building envelope is not as easy as looking directly above a puddle.

Oftentimes, moisture intrusion can be a reoccurring problem that leaves maintenance crews tracking leaks and attempting to bandage suspected sources. As a result, solutions are often knee-jerk reactions to the moisture and are hastily conceived without much investigation or thought.

Fortunately, there are methods for recognizing moisture sources and for ensuring that moisture control is a proactive process as opposed to a reactive one.

Identifying Moisture Sources

A systematic approach to moisture control is the most efficient alternative to constantly “putting out fires.” Admittedly, unless a building has been perfectly designed and maintained, moisture mitigation will always start with a reaction to a problem. The proper reaction is to investigate thoroughly all the potential sources of moisture intrusion until the source is identified. Only then can the proper solution be developed and implemented. Thorough investigation begins with utilizing appropriate tools and methods to create a theory for moisture mitigation. Investigation can range from general scanning to more specific sampling.

roofing maintenance
The source of water within a building is often difficult to identify. (Photo: The Garland Company, Inc.)

Single Ply Roofing Industry (SPRI) recommends beginning searches inside the building, starting with walls and ceilings. The interior condition will often direct the exterior visual investigation. When scanning for leak causes, it is important to keep in mind the common causes of roof problems. The National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA) Manual of Roof Maintenance and Repair lists common causes of roof problems and states that the “greatest cause of premature roof problems” is lack of maintenance. Other contributors according to the manual include weathering, wind damage, improper design, drainage, and a myriad of material and flashing issues.

Visual Investigation For Moisture Intrusion

Visual investigation is the simplest and most easily accomplished method of investigation. Visual investigation can be used to generate theories that can later be validated with other techniques. Visual investigation involves casing a building and inspecting the roof and walls for obvious potential moisture sources. A comprehensive visual inspection may reveal failing materials, faulty installation, or poor detailing—all potential sources of moisture within the building.  Special attention should be placed upon details, joints, flashings, and any other discontinuities or terminations.

roofing maintenance
A thorough roof investigation requires investigation of flashings for cracks. (Photo: The Garland Company, Inc.)

SPRI specifically recommends the following details in order of importance as critical for visual inspection:

  • Cap Flashing
  • Edge Metal
  • Base Flashing
  • Penetrations
  • Field of Roof
  • Ballast
  • Roof Adhesive and Surface Coatings

The NRCA Manual of Roof Maintenance and Repair reinforces SPRI’s emphasis on the criticality of flashing inspection and states that “many early roof problems are actually flashing problems” and that “the importance of maintaining them cannot be overemphasized.”

Moisture Scans

roofing maintenance
Warm spots discovered in infrared scans indicate wet materials in a roof assembly. (Photo: The Garland Company, Inc.)

If visual inspections do not conclusively establish a source of moisture intrusion, an infrared or nuclear scan can be used to shed more light on where moisture may be located in a roof assembly. Further, any issues or concerns revealed during a visual inspection can be validated by a moisture scan. Infrared scans are often performed at night when a roof or wall surface cools down as the heat absorbed from the sun dissipates. Because moisture retains heat better than most materials, warmer temperatures often indicate the presence of moisture. Thermal images provide a map of plausible moisture sources. Meanwhile, nuclear scans are necessary over gravel and ballast surfaced roof assemblies where infrared does not work as well. Once moisture scans are complete, core cuts should then be taken to visually verify results.

Core Cuts

A core cut is the most intrusive of investigation techniques and involves cutting into the roof or wall substrate to obtain an understanding of the components within the assembly. A core cut on a roof or wall may validate information gathered from visual investigations and infrared scans that have been conducted. Special attention should be paid to where within the assembly moisture is first noticed. For instance, if moisture is noticed on the bottom of roof insulation (between the deck and the insulation), that is an indication that moisture may be accumulating from the inside of the building or that the moisture is finding a path inside from a location not directly above the location of the core cut.

Information gathered from a core cut can also be used to predict the performance of a wall or roof based upon the materials and the order they were installed.

Hygrothermal Analysis

If the investigation above leads one to believe that condensation is causing the moisture problem, a hygrothermal analysis may be conducted. Hygrothermal analysis software programs, such as WUFI, use known information or predictions regarding a roof or wall assembly and the internal and external environment to predict moisture mitigation through the various assembly materials. A hygrothermal analysis cannot be used to locate a “leak” in the typical sense, but can create a reasonable hypothesis of the way moisture moves through a particular assembly and whether that moisture should be expected to condense within the assembly.

Problems recognized from hygrothermal analysis are typically relegated to faulty design, faulty detailing, or failing material. Predictions made from other investigations can be validated by the hygrothermal analysis and can then be used to present a solution.

Addressing Issues

After a thorough building investigation, a solution can be proposed for addressing the suspected cause of moisture. The proper solution may range from a simple patch, to the generation and installation of a new detail, or it may require the proper application of a specific product. In any instance, a comprehensive preventive maintenance program is a good start to prevent future issues.

According to SPRI an inspection routine should be employed during transition periods between seasons, as well as after severe events like storms or unusual weather.

Major focus points of good preventive maintenance are things often overlooked. The list of potential points of surveillance is extensive, and it is not limited to those listed in this article. Debris buildup blocking a drain can lead to water ponding and flooding a roof. Sealants should be checked to ensure they have not become brittle due to exposure to the sun or from aging. Aged roofs or flashing membranes may be cracked and could benefit from restoration with a reflective coating. Masonry walls may have spalling joints that need to be re-tuck pointed, or the wall may need to be coated to prevent the masonry from absorbing moisture.

The list can go on, and oftentimes a custom set of solutions and recommendations must be generated based on the particular details of a building.

The following steps for prevention of roof issues should be adhered to:

  • Maintain a clean roof.
  • Train maintenance crews regarding the intricacies of the particular roof system.
  • Monitor drainage systems, and ensure they remain functional.
  • Limit roof access to authorized personnel.
  • Perform a formal, consistent roof inspection at least once a year.
  • For proper maintenance and inspection, facility managers should turn to partners who can provide guidance in identifying problems, proper repair material selection, and quality installation. Full-service manufacturers are ideally suited as they can bring together the expertise, material, and qualified contractors to extend the life of buildings.

Sources

1  National Roofing Contractors Association, “NRCA/ARMA Manual of Roof Maintenance and Repair,” 1988
2  Single Ply Roofing Industry, “How to Implement A Roof Maintenance Program”

roofEndredi is a project engineer for The Garland Company, Inc., a Cleveland, OH based manufacturer of roofing and building envelope solutions. In his role, Endredi develops code compliant and waterproof designs, among other responsibilities.

Do you have a comment? Share your thoughts in the Comments section below or send an e-mail to the Editor at [email protected]

You Might Like:

LEAVE A REPLY