FM Issue: Copper Theft
By Keith Jentoft
Published in the August 2010 issue of Today’s Facility Manager
Facilities management (FM) is afflicted with a growing infection eating at the wiring, sucking at the plumbing, rupturing the HVAC, and suppressing fire control. The plague of copper theft is a facilities cancer destroying value and killing property—an epidemic in need of a cure.
Over the past five years copper prices have skyrocketed. While there was brief relief during the market crash, prices have again surged, driving the epidemic of copper theft cancer.
Deceptive Price Tags
In the past few years, rising commodities prices created new challenges for facility managers (fms) and placed building infrastructure under new attacks. Most shocking to those who have not lived through an episode are the unbelievable repair costs relative to the value of the copper stolen.
It would be difficult to exaggerate the gap between the scrap prices thieves collect and what management pays to rectify what vandals leave behind. The cost to repair a rooftop HVAC system hit by copper thieves for $400 of cooling coils often is more than one hundred times the value of the copper.
The horror stories are everywhere—on television news, radio reports, and the local papers. Supermarkets, hospitals, and schools are shut down because thieves targeted their HVAC systems. Vacant offices and apartments are stripped of their wiring and left with a patchwork of holes in the drywall used to pull wiring from the studs. Sprinkler valves and fittings are disappearing, threatening safety and building code compliance.
“Do Not Enter” Does Not Matter
In the past, the intrinsic value of wiring, plumbing, roofing, and HVAC didn’t merit the labor required to steal it for scrap. Not anymore. Older buildings are especially vulnerable, as they are a virtual mine of copper pipes, copper wires, and copper gutters/flashing; all built when copper cost pennies a pound and needed no protection.
Spools of copper wire, new boilers, emergency generators, or uninstalled cooling systems have always needed protection during construction. Once they were installed, however, nobody worried about them. This has changed, and proactive fms are exploring ways to protect what is theirs and avoid the catastrophic costs associated with repairing copper theft.
The trouble is that normal burglary involves thieves stealing valuables contained in a building. With copper theft crooks steal the “building” itself, often without even entering the facility.
Traditional intrusion alarm systems are not designed to prevent the theft of gutters or HVAC units. The costs can be very high.
In January of this year, Jefferson County Public Schools near Louisville, KY had copper gutters taken from 14 schools. The local news, WLKY, reported the following: “The Jefferson County Public Schools executive director of facilities, Michael Mulheirn, said copper gutters and copper flashing started disappearing from school rooftops two months ago. ‘The worse thing that can happen is obviously we can get water into the building,’ said Mulheirn. ‘It can also, if you’re not careful, it can get into the roofing system and insulation underneath, and that’s when you can eventually end up with indoor air quality problems.’
“WLKY called several scrap yards around town to find out how much the thieves are getting for the stolen copper. The average was about $2.85 per pound, but only about $1.30 if it has tar on it. Mulheirn said the cost to fix the damage that’s been done at all 14 schools will be $100,000.”
Again, the cost to repair is orders of magnitude more than the value of the scrap as seen when thieves ransack rooftop HVAC systems. Ted Davis of Oklahoma City had 18 rooftop HVAC units stolen from the roof of his business. He estimated the cost to repair the damage at between $130,000 and $140,000 while the value for the scrap aluminum and copper was about $9,000. Obviously, this doesn’t consider the cost of downtime.
The large cooling systems in supermarkets and hospitals are prime targets. A recent incident in California forced a large supermarket to close while new cooling units were installed and the roof was repaired. The cost of the actual repairs was $250,000, but the cost of downtime and spoilage was even greater. Even without food freezers to worry about, in many parts of the country in the Sunbelt, losing air conditioning means closing the building until it is repaired.
Some fms are finding a solution to copper theft with video alarms designed for use outdoors. Video alarms are different from traditional surveillance systems and CCTV cameras that already are present in many facilities.
Surveillance systems typically use DVRs to record video from the surveillance cameras continuously for later review in the event of a problem. As any police officer will affirm, outdoor thieves are rarely identified with surveillance video recordings. The obvious flaw with recorded video is that by the time the problem is discovered, the crooks are long gone, and all that is left is an image of the back of their sweatshirt and the top of their baseball cap.
Video alarm systems are designed to detect intruders and notify police immediately, sending a 10 second video clip of what caused the alarm to a monitoring station for review and police dispatch. This means police respond to a crime in progress and can catch the crooks in the act.
One significant benefit of this approach is that police give priority response to video alarms. They support video alarms because they make more arrests. Because video alarm systems confirm the presence of an intruder, fms aren’t saddled with increasing fines for false alarms, and police arrest the perpetrators.
On October 12 to 15, 2010, thousands of security management professionals from around the world, along with hundreds of product manufacturers and service providers, will gather at the Dallas Convention Center in Dallas, TX for the ASIS International 56th Annual Seminar and Exhibits (www.asis2010.org). ASIS 2010 is the most comprehensive education and networking event in the security industry. More than 20,000 professionals from all vertical industries and government sectors, from Fortune 100 companies to the Department of Homeland Security, will be in attendance.
“No other security event attracts the numbers of higher level practitioners and executives,” says ASIS International President Joseph R. (Bob) Granger, CPP. “It’s the best place to meet peers face to face, share information and best practices, and discover how others are solving their security challenges in today’s complex environment.”
ASIS 2010 attendees will be able to pursue professional development opportunities and choose from more than 160 educational sessions that address timely security topics and critical issues. Attendees will be able to select from among 18 comprehensive tracks to design personalized programs. Track categories include crime and loss prevention; crisis management; critical infrastructure; government/military; information protection; physical security; and terrorism.
There are many sessions focused on the interests of facilities managers (fms), including the following:
• “Proactive Approaches, Tools, and Equipment That Can Increase Safety and Security in Parking Structures”
• “Making the Decision: Transitioning from Proprietary Security to Contract Security”
• “21st Century CPTED and Infrastructure Protection”
• “Premises Liability: A Trial Lawyer’s Hints for the Security Professional”
• “Focus on Security Lighting”
• “Mass Notification and Rapid Response”
Some 750 manufacturers, inventors, service providers, and entrepreneurs will showcase everything from IP technology, biometrics, thermal imaging devices, robotics, explosives detection, and more. The exhibits are open Tuesday through Thursday, October 12 to 14, from 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Admission to the exhibits is free with advance registration. ASIS Accolades award winners will be highlighted during the popular “What’s New on the Floor” session, scheduled for Tuesday, October 12 at 1:45 p.m.
Keynote speakers at ASIS 2010 include Pervez Musharraf, former president of Pakistan, and pilot Chesley B. Sullenberger III. President Musharraf will share his experiences on Thursday, October 14 at 8 a.m. Captain of what has been dubbed the “Miracle on the Hudson,” Sullenberger is an aviation safety expert and accident investigator. He will speak on Wednesday, October 13 at 8 a.m. On Friday, October 15, humorist and best selling author Dave Barry will address attendees at the closing luncheon.
Networking events include the ASIS Foundation 14th Annual Golf Classic; various receptions, including ones for young professionals and women in security; breakfasts and luncheons; and Law Enforcement/Military Appreciation Day (Thursday, October 14).
For more details and registration information, go to www.asis2010.org, or follow ASIS 2010 on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Twitter.
In the May 2010 issue of Sheriff magazine, Larry Amerson, the incoming president of the National Sheriffs’ Association stated, “We believe that the delivery of a video of the specific event that triggered the alarm is a tremendous improvement in alarm technology that will lead to a reduction in false alarms, saving valuable budget dollars.”
Vacant, But Not Empty
Vacant property presents a special set of problems. Protecting vacant property is a growing issue as copper theft threatens the integrity of the buildings themselves. Once the wiring or sprinkler systems have been damaged, everything must be brought back up to code before anything can be done with the property.
Vacant property often means that power, broadband, and/or phone is unavailable. Most importantly, securing vacant property often means investing money to install wires and cameras in a building that is going to be renovated or sold (which is often a losing proposition to be avoided).
Cordless/wireless video alarm systems change the game and are an affordable option to protect vacant property against copper theft. Aside from the fact that they still catch criminals in the act, these systems install instantly and can be moved as needed.
One example of how this can be implemented is a cordless motion viewer, which consists of a relatively small (about the size of a coffee cup) integrated detector/camera. This type of equipment can be placed on a tripod or attached to a surface with Velcro or magnetic mounts, so they can be reconfigured as needed or moved when the facility is sold.
Case Study: Detroit Schools
One example of how effective video alarms can be happened recently in the Detroit Public Schools. Detroit closed many schools in 2009; some were scheduled for remodeling and others were being readied for sale.
A true surveillance system with wired CCTV cameras would have cost $100,000 per site and required several days to install. This was impossible given the financial challenges of the Detroit school system.
Ultimately, Detroit opted to protect 30 buildings using cordless/wireless video security provided by a local integrator. These systems cost 5% of the surveillance systems and overcame the hurdle of affordability. A team of four people installed 30 systems in six days.
These “5% solutions” actually performed better than the $100,000 systems in terms of arrests. In their first month of operation, September 2009, the systems assisted the police in making over 45 arrests. In the months following the total has grown to over 90.
Detroit has demonstrated that success is possible on a budget. Law enforcement officials strongly support the solution, and they are publicizing the arrests to send a message to the surrounding community: “Don’t steal here, or we will catch you and prosecute to the fullest extent of the law.”
Fortunately, with the help of video alarm technology, vacant and occupied buildings can now be secured on budget and protected from the cancer of copper theft without breaking the bank
Read an online article from FacilityBlog that discusses copper theft instances and what some officials have done about them. Do you have a comment? Share your thoughts by writing to email@example.com, or search for additional articles on this subject in the TFM online archives.